Editorial Review Product Description She may be a miracle, but she’s no Proper Young Lady!
It isn’t easy being a pioneer in the state of Washington in 1899, but it’s particularly hard when you are the only girl ever born in the new settlement. With seven older brothers and a love of adventure, May Amelia Jackson just can’t seem to abide her family’s insistence that she behave like a Proper Young Lady. Not when there’s fishing to be done, sheep to be herded, and real live murderers to be captured! May is sure she could manage better if only there were at least one other girl living along the banks of the Nasel River. And now that Mama’s going to have a baby, maybe there’s hope. . . .Amazon.com Review Twelve-year-old May Amelia is too busy chasing sheep, fishing for salmon,and keeping pace with the antics of her seven Finnish brothers to botherwearing a dress or scrubbing behind her ears. Unfortunately, she's beingpressured to clean up her act. "It seems like everyone is conspiring tomake me a Proper Young Lady," she observes in frustration. "I do not thinkbeing a proper Young Lady sounds like any fun at all."The old-fashioned language in this historical novel seems strained attimes, and the quirky use of capital letters is an unnecessary distraction,but this book is still a lot of fun. Why? For one thing, the story is setin the far, untamed reaches of the West at the turn of the 20th century,and offers encounters with Chinook Indians, dark forests, and the twistsand turns of the Nasel River. And then there is May Amelia--asheadstrong as rushing water, and the only female born on this stretch ofthe river since her family can remember. She is known (when she's not deepinto trouble) as the Miracle. Will this feisty female ever settle down andbecome the little lady everyone expects her to be? Will her pregnant mothergive birth to another girl so May Amelia can finally have a sister? You'llhave to read the whole story to find out. (Ages 10 and older) --MariaDolan ... Read more Customer Reviews (98)
Warning for parents
I'm so glad I read this book before giving it to my voracious, but sensitive readers ages 8 and 10.May Amelia is a well developed character, and my daughters would definitely relate to her and be interested in her story.But, the sweet baby sister she has always longed for dies while in May Amelia's care.May Amelia wakes up feeling relieved to have such a good night sleep without the baby crying, and then realizes that she's dead.It has haunted me ever since I've read it, and I have adult skills for coping with all the suffering in this world.
It's one thing to read about infant deaths in pioneer times in a history book, but in this case, an empathetic reader is going to feel the shock and grief that the character is feeling, and the guilt also.The baby's death and it's aftermath are the central events of the book.
May Amelia Jackson, the only Jackson girl
The best book ever written. Since reading this in 2007, I have searched for another May Amelia in reading 100 more books. I have not found another May Amelia.There is a grief chapter, who would have thought.It is written with a touching sense of wonder I consider Top Of The Line. This book is my ITS A WONDERFUL LIFE of books.I savor for when I will be able to read it again. It is not a perfect book though, at least for first time through. But upon multiple readings, you forgive for the minor and expected imperfections and it becomes a perfect book to you. The audio book version of the book is the only audio book I have ever really liked.It is read by a young girl (now a movie star), and the book is in first person. There is none of the usual false dramatization given by adult readers, the dramatization is just natural. The reader does seem to embody the character.
A great novel for all ages.
I'm a little late in reviewing this book, but I couldn't resist writing one anyway. I read it for the first time when I was 8, and read it again yesterday (being 12 now), and have enjoyed it both times.
The story follows an 12-year-old May Amelia Jackson, an adventurous tomboy living in 1899 with her seven older brothers. I'll try not to spoil the ending for you, but May gets into plenty of trouble and can never learn to be a proper young lady. Life only gets harder when death strikes the family. It's not the most action-packed book ever, but it's still intriguing and exciting.
I disagree with two complaints about the book, the first being that the novel is violent and inappropriate for children. Yes, the abusive behavior displayed toward the children by their grandmother can be scary for children. Parents should certainly be aware of that before buying the book. But let's face it - there are mean and abusive people, and it's a part of life. And the violence is nothing too graphic. So skip that chapter if you don't like it - but even if you don't, you won't be scarred for life.
The second is that the book's lack of quotation marks and random capitalization of words is distracting and strange. But I think it only makes the story more realistic. Since it's told from May Amelia's point of view, and she's Finnish and doesn't speak perfect English, her less-than-perfect grammar makes it seem like she really wrote this and makes the reader really get to know May. It's not just a description of her life, it really is her. Also, the capitalization isn't random - it's for emphasis, and again, it's more realistic this way. A real 12-year-old girl could've written it.
Rather Dull
I can't believe this was a Newbery Honor book. Pickin's must've been slim that year. The first half of this book is dull, just ordinary information about the character's life. It's not until about half way through that there's any kind of conflict--a bit too long to wait. But the second half of the book isn't much better than the first. And the ending was lacking. The characters in the book spoke using no contractions, which I found odd. I don't know anyone who speaks without using contractions. I don't think they even did that back in 1900. It made reading the dialogue somewhat ackward. I notice that other children's writers do this too. But I don't understand why. This book has a lot in common with Boston Jane. Both characters are tomboys, they spit, the Chinook Indians, and there's even a character in this book by the name of Jane. I liked the Boston Jane series, but not this book. i just though it was a bit dull.
May Amelia-miracle child
May Amelia the main character grows up with an all boy house at the turn of the 1900's. The author Jennifer L. Holm does a great job capturing the readers attention. In every chapter there is suspense and excitment like when she got chased up a tree by a mother bear, or when she almost got killed by a rushing stream of logs and was saved by an incredable string of luck. This book should fill childrens libraries,and in my opinion is one of the best books I have ever read. If I were you I would check it out!!!!!!!
... Read more |